This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.
Some content on this site is AI-assisted and reviewed by our editorial team.
Every Thanksgiving has the same bottleneck, and it isn’t the turkey — it’s the oven. By 11 AM on the big day, the main cavity is fully booked: bird in, sides queued behind it, the rolls waiting their turn like cars at a ferry dock. The hosts who look relaxed are the ones running a second oven, and the cheapest second oven in America right now is an electric roaster that costs about sixty dollars and eats a 28-pound bird.
An electric roaster is a big insulated tub with a heating element — it roasts, it steams, it bakes casseroles, and it frees the real oven for the dishes that actually need browning. Here’s the honest tiering, plus the automation trick that makes the cheap ones better.
Hamilton Beach 22-Quart Roaster Oven — The $60 workhorse
This is the default answer and has been for years: 22 quarts, fits up to a 28-pound turkey, 150 to 450 degrees, with a self-basting lid that does a genuinely decent job keeping the breast from drying out. It’s the size that handles Thanksgiving for a crowd and doubles as a buffet warmer the rest of the year — which is how a “one-day appliance” earns its shelf space.
The honest con everyone learns the first year: it steams more than it browns. The skin comes out pale, and the finishing move is 15 minutes in the real oven at high heat — which you now have, because the real oven is free. My take: the buy, full stop. This is the machine that changes the logistics of the day for the price of a grocery-store flower arrangement.
NutriChef 18-Quart Roaster Oven — The mid-size alternative
Same idea, smaller tub: the 18-quart handles up to roughly a 22-pound bird and takes meaningfully less counter and cupboard space. For a household of six doing one 14-pounder, 18 quarts is the honest fit, and the lid handles fit normal cabinets.
Con: stock and pricing on this model swing by seller, so verify the listing and the live price before you build your plan around it. My take: the right size for smaller birds and smaller kitchens.
Oster 22-Quart Roaster Oven — The big-box staple
The other default 22-quart pick, usually the doorbuster deal of the category on Black Friday week — which, timing-wise, is exactly now. Oster’s version is functionally interchangeable with the Hamilton Beach: same capacity class, same self-basting lid idea, same pale-skin limitation.
Con: availability cycles — it sells out in November and gets re-listed by third parties at silly prices in December. If you see it at a sane number, that’s the moment. My take: buy whichever of the two 22-quarts is cheaper the week you’re shopping; there’s no wrong answer between them.
Proctor Silex 18-Quart Roaster — The bare-bones budget pick
The cheapest name-brand roaster on the shelf, for the one-holiday-a-year kitchen. It heats, it holds a turkey, it asks nothing of you — which is exactly the deal at the bottom of any appliance category.
Con: single-knob control with no indicator light and no bell, so “is it on” and “is it ready” are your problems. My take: if the choice is this or oven gridlock, take this — but the ten extra dollars for a dial you can read from across the kitchen is money well spent.
Kasa Smart Plug Mini 4-Pack (EP25) — The automation add-on

Here’s the trick worth the whole post: put the mechanical-dial roaster on a smart plug, and you get a phone-killable schedule without trusting a budget appliance’s nonexistent app. Start the roaster from the couch, cut power from the driveway, get a reminder that the thing is still on. About $12 a plug in a 4-pack, and the other three plugs will have colonized the lamps by Friday.
The honest limit: a plug only cuts power — it doesn’t turn a dial or hold a temperature, so dial-based cooking still needs a human timer check. My take: the best twelve dollars in holiday kitchen automation, especially for the Proctor Silex tier with no indicator light of its own.
Prime tip: roasters sell out the week of Thanksgiving — a Prime trial gets you two-day shipping, which is the difference between “ordered in time” and “roasting in a cooler full of hot water.”
What Actually Saves the Day (And What Doesn’t)
Capacity honesty. 18 quarts ≈ 22-pound bird; 22 quarts ≈ 28-pound bird. Buy for the bird you actually cook, not the one you imagine.
The steam problem is real but cheap to fix. Transfer to the real oven for the last 15 minutes for skin — the roaster did the time-consuming part.
Warming is the underrated job. On the day, the roaster at 200 degrees is the best holding station in the house — better than the oven, because it frees it.
Skip: roaster accessories that promise baking pans and pizza. It’s a big hot tub; bread it is not a bread oven.
The Savings Math
- The roaster route: about $60 once, plus $12 for the smart plug — and the real oven is free all day, every year after.
- The alternative “second oven”: a wall oven install or a countertop convection that does one dish at a time, starting around 10× the price for the cheap ones.
- What it’s really worth: dishes finishing on time, no 40-minute roll backlog, and a host at the table instead of at the oven door.
Keep reading: our Thanksgiving-eve slow cooker piece covers the other make-ahead appliance, and the smart kettle guide handles the morning-after logistics.
CleverHomeClub is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. That means if you buy through one of the links above, I get a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend devices I’d run in my own home.
🏠 Get Your Free Smart Home Setup Checklist
Join our newsletter and get this free printable plus weekly tips.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do roaster ovens cook a turkey as well as a real oven?
The meat turns out moist — the self-basting lids genuinely help — but the skin comes out pale because a roaster steams rather than browns. The standard fix: finish the bird in the real oven for the last 15 minutes at high heat, which you'll have free.
What size roaster oven do I need?
An 18-quart roaster fits roughly a 22-pound turkey; a 22-quart handles up to about 28 pounds. Buy for the bird you actually cook — most households never need more than 18 quarts.
Can a smart plug control a roaster oven?
Partly. A smart plug adds a phone-killable power switch and a schedule, which works well on mechanical-dial models — but it can't turn the dial or regulate temperature, so dial-based cooking still needs a human timer check.
Is a roaster oven worth it outside Thanksgiving?
Yes — at 200 degrees it's the best buffet warmer in the house for any gathering, and it bakes casseroles and keeps rolls hot. That second job is what justifies the cupboard space.
Does a roaster oven use less electricity than the main oven?
It uses less power than a full-size oven thanks to its smaller heated cavity, though the difference is modest — the real saving is logistical: it doubles your cooking capacity during the one meal where capacity is everything.
Liked this guide? Get the next one in your inbox — the smart home starter checklist is free too.
✓ You're in — check your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. We never share your email.